We are often asked if we can date a particular toy. Well, sometimes we can
and here is how we do it and how you can too:
Identify the maker - Look carefully for a
manufacturer's mark. If the maker can be identified, dating the toy becomes much
easier. Sometimes a maker changes the name of their toy company at a certain
date, then they changed the toy labels, all the while the toy remained the same.
Frantz Manufacturing did this. Their early toys were identified with Frantz
while later ones were labeled Hustler Toys. There is a transitional period when
they applied Hustler decals over the Frantz marks.
Look at the style - Toys, like clothing
and automobiles, reflect the style of their era. During the Art Deco period of
the 1920s and 1930s, toys tended to take on an Art Deco look themselves. Dolls
of this period had hair styles of the period - the flapper look. Also, manufacturers often
retained only one or two toy designers, so their toys generally look similar.
The manufacturers often shared components between toys to save on production
Check parts material - Check the
materials that the toy was made from. Plastic was introduced into toys in the
late 1920s but not in any great amount. By the late 1930s, plastic was being
used commonly but still not as the main material. By 1955, most toys were being
made with plastic because of the low production costs. Glass eyes usually indicate an early age. Metal was in short supply during WWII so toys of that period contains little
or no metal.
Before WWI, a lot of toys and toy part came from Europe - mainly Germany and
France. These included glass eyes and bisque heads for dolls.
WWI interrupted this supply and manufacturers changed to their own
designs - painting the eyes on instead of using glass eyes, for example.
Check a patent number - Sometimes a toy
has a patent number stamped on it. Look up the patent. We have instructions for
viewing patents on this site. Remember that the patent issue date provides
a possible early date of manufacture but not necessarily the earliest. The
company may have been making the toy for several years before a patent was
granted. The toy could have been made for many years after the
Do a patent search - For toys made before
1976, you will have to search the Patent Repositories located throughout the
country. You almost have to search page-by-page. You had better have a lot of
time to devote to this! Some toys had the usual Utility Patent and some were
"Design Patented". A "Utility Patent" protects a unique
mechanism of the toy. A "Design Patent" protects its artistic design and
an illustration will appear on the patent. The patent date will be there.
This is hard and time consuming, often without good results since only a
fraction of the toys made every were patented. A few toys are only known from a
Look at the characters - Some toys are
based on popular cartoon characters. Find out when these characters first
appeared. Some cartoon characters underwent changes over the years and this can
help pin down a period for the toy. For example, Donald Duck made his cartoon
debut in 1934 with long beak which underwent a shortening in 1937 or 1938.
Research Toy publications - There are toy
industry magazines that have been published over many years. Playthings Magazine
has been publishing since about 1902 and is still publishing. Their archives are
open for research at a high cost - $500 a week I understand. But they are an
excellent source of toy research material.
Search manufacturer's catalogs - Collectors
are very eager to obtain original or copies of original toy manufacturer's sales
catalogs. These are usually dated and contain drawings or photos of the
Check the internet - Sometimes a Google
search can reveal information about the toy. There are good sites for Fisher
Price, push puppets, Schoenhut, and a few others. You have to know the
manufacturer or the type or style of the toy (pull, push, push puppets, doll,
circus) to do an effective search.
Consult with collectors - Collectors who specialize
in a few makers or a toy type usually have collected a great body of information
they are willing to share. We have a few collectors participating on this site
who might be able to help. A list of collectors is also given in O'Brien's
Wear - Be careful judging a toy's age
from the amount of wear on it. Old toys can be unused and in near mint
condition. New toys can be worn out. I haven't found that wear is an indication